Twice a week in Ubud, eight to twelve people sit around a long table with three decks of cards. Each person draws one card, reads the question aloud, and answers it about their own life. Nothing has to be resolved. Two hours later some of them will say it was the most honest conversation they have had in years.
This post is my attempt to understand why the Game works and what it does to participants.
After some research, I have found that however astute, the questions are mostly a pretext. What changes people over a session is twofold:
The discovery that a struggle they held as private evidence of defect is in fact ordinary,
The experience of saying it aloud in a room that acknowledges and does not try to fix it.
I have identified five mechanisms that do most of the work, and all five are well documented in the psychological literature.
The Trojan Horse
Three decks of cards, nearly one hundred questions each. It can look like the active ingredient. Yet the efficient container is more likely to be the social agreement:
The permission to be oneself authentically.
Three features of the format make this visible.
The card is drawn at random. Nobody knows you or your situation. So nobody chose the card for you and nobody is implying anything by asking.
You read it to yourself and answer it yourself. So nothing is being put to you by a person who might have a motive.
The same card put to eight people produces eight unrelated responses. Because what surfaces is governed by what is already alive in the person not by the words in front of them.
The harder questions only tell the group what kind of room the participant is choosing to play with (which saves the long and boring minutes a group normally takes negotiating depth). The harder questions do not, on their own, produce the deeper effect. Gentler questions, set inside the same structure and with the same facilitation, produce similar results.
So where is the work happening really? The game is not about clever questions. It is a set of conditions under which ordinary people say true things and are received.
The conditions are doing more than the content.
1- Universality
Most people carry their central difficulty as private evidence that something is wrong with them specifically. They are comparing their own interior, which they know in full, against everyone else’s exterior, which is edited.
The comparison is rigged.
Social psychology has a name for the resulting error. Pluralistic ignorance describes a state in which people privately hold a position they believe almost nobody else holds, while everyone around them is quietly in the same position. Floyd Allport described the pattern in 1924, and he and Daniel Katz named it in 1931.
The cleanest demonstration is Prentice and Miller’s 1993 study of drinking at Princeton. Students were, on average, less comfortable with campus drinking practices than they believed their peers to be, while their actual comfort levels were much the same as each other’s. The misperception had consequences: over a semester, men’s private attitudes drifted toward the norm they had imagined, and the further a student believed themselves to be from that norm, the more alienated from campus they felt. The isolation was produced by the error, not by any real difference.
This (the correction of the private error) is the mechanism the Game interrupts most directly. Participants name fear, stagnation, shame or self-deception in sequence, out loud, with specifics. Nobody argues anyone out of anything. The correction arrives as evidence rather than as reassurance, which is why it holds afterwards.
Irvin Yalom placed the same effect among the therapeutic factors in group psychotherapy and called it universality. It sits among twelve such factors, among catharsis and group cohesiveness.
What the authenticity game does is run several of these factors at once in a compressed form.
2- Responsiveness
This is the finding that reframed the whole Game for me, and it runs against my intuitive reading.
The intuitive reading is that disclosure produces closeness: the more someone reveals, the closer the room gets. There is real support for part of this. Collins and Miller’s 1994 meta-analysis in Psychological Bulletin established three separate effects.
People who disclose intimately are liked more than those who stay shallow.
People disclose more to those they already like.
And people come to like those who have disclosed to them.
But the disclosure is only the opening move. Reis and Shaver’s interpersonal process model of intimacy, set out in 1988, holds that intimacy emerges from a transaction: one person discloses something personally meaningful, the other responds in a way that conveys understanding, validation and care, and the first person perceives that response.
It is the perception of responsiveness, not the disclosure, that converts the exchange into felt closeness.
Laurenceau, Feldman Barrett and Rovine tested this directly in a daily-diary study of ninety-six married couples, published in 2005. What they could measure was that perceived responsiveness carried roughly three times the weight of the disclosure itself.
Translated into the room: what a person says matters less than what happens in the two minutes after they say it.
A disclosure met with distraction, correction, or a competing story produces nothing, or worse than nothing. The same disclosure met with evident attention and an unhurried follow-up question produces the effect the whole session is for.
This also explains why facilitation is not decoration. The facilitator’s real function is not to supply better questions. It is to guarantee responsiveness when the group fails to generate it: to ask the one follow-up that demonstrates somebody was listening closely, and to prevent the room from doing the things that cancel a disclosure.
3- Speaking
People sometimes answer a card without needing anything in return. They are not transmitting a finished thought. They are finding out what they think by hearing it leave their mouth with witnesses present, which is a different cognitive act.
Three bodies of work converge here.
Affect labeling. Lieberman and colleagues, in a 2007 fMRI study, found that putting a feeling into words reduced activity in the amygdala and other limbic regions.
Naming a feeling is not merely describing it. It changes the state being named.
Expressive disclosure. Pennebaker’s writing paradigm has generated a large experimental literature on what happens when people put difficult experience into language. Frattaroli’s 2006 review of 146 experiments found a real effect.
What it establishes is that the act of articulation does something on its own, independent of any listener.
The weight of what goes unsaid. Slepian, Chun and Mason’s 2017 work on secrecy found something counterintuitive about why secrets are burdensome. The cost is not mainly the effort of hiding a secret. People rarely have to actively conceal anything. What wears them down is that they keep thinking about it — on a walk, in the shower, lying awake — when nothing has prompted it at all.
That last finding explains a specific thing people may report after the game: relief disproportionate to what was actually revealed.
Saying something aloud once, to people who will not do anything with it, changes its status from a thing being carried to a thing that has been said.
The carrying was the expensive part.
Speaking here does what thinking cannot.
4- Liking
Two findings sit behind the share: I thought I had said too much, and then nobody treated me as though I had.
The liking gap. Boothby, Cooney, Sandstrom and Clark, publishing in Psychological Science in 2018, showed that after a conversation people systematically underestimate how much their partner liked them and enjoyed their company. The gap held across conversations from two minutes to forty-five. Among students sharing a suite it persisted for most of an academic year.
People are liked more than they know, and they stay wrong about it for a long time.
The beautiful mess effect. Bruk, Scholl and Bless, also in 2018, found an asymmetry in how vulnerability is evaluated. Imagining oneself showing vulnerability, people rate it as weakness and mess. Observing someone else do the same thing, they rate it as courage and desirability.
The identical act is read differently depending on which side of it you are standing.
Put together, these describe the internal experience of a difficult card with some precision. The person expects exposure to cost them something. It buys them something instead, and they are the last to know it.
Someone who plays several times accumulates enough counter-evidence to begin recalibrating, which is probably one reason the people who return find it easier each time.
There is a corollary worth noticing. Because the prediction error is near-universal in the room, every person is simultaneously overestimating their own exposure and admiring everyone else’s.
The group is more generous than any individual in it believes.
5- Reception
The rule that nothing has to be resolved is the least obvious design decision in the game and probably the most important one.
Consider what ordinarily happens when somebody says something difficult. The listener offers advice. Or reassurance. Or a matching story of their own. Each of these is well-intentioned and each one quietly declines what was offered. Advice reframes the person as a problem to be solved. Reassurance disputes their account. A matching story moves the attention.
The common feature is that the disclosure is treated as a prompt for the listener’s own action rather than as something to be received.
Against Reis and Shaver’s model, this is the failure of responsiveness in three varieties. Understanding, validation and care are precisely what those moves fail to convey, however warmly they are meant.
A room where completion is not expected removes the pressure that generates all three. Nobody has to produce a solution, so nobody reaches for one. The person finishes speaking, the room holds it, the next card is drawn.
For many people this is the first time an adult life has offered them that, and it is often the part they cannot name afterwards when asked what was good about the session.
It also protects the format from drifting into group therapy, which it is not. A therapeutic frame implies a contract about depth, duration, containment and aftercare that a session with strangers cannot honor. The no-resolution rule is what keeps the game inside its own competence: it can offer reception, universality and the experience of being heard.
Not for Everyone?
Some people play once and never return. The mechanisms above predict why, and the reason is not boredom.
If the central benefit is the “correction of pluralistic ignorance”, then the failure mode is the correction not perceived. A person listens to others and still experiences themselves as categorically different. They leave with their isolation confirmed rather than dissolved, now with an audience. The same mechanism that heals in one direction wounds in the other.
A second route to the same exit: the gap between the depth a card requests and the depth a person is willing to go on that session. Nothing forces anyone to close that gap, and what fills it instead is performance, an answer that has the shape of disclosure without the substance. The person usually knows. Having performed authenticity in a room convened for authenticity is an uncomfortable thing to take home, and not coming back resolves it.
Third, responsiveness can simply fail. A room that is tired, or crowded, or two cards past its attention span will receive somebody’s hardest material with a nod and move on. Nothing visibly goes wrong. Nothing much happens either, and a person whose one session landed in that window has no reason to think the format works.
None of these are arguments against the design. They are the predictable shadow of a format whose power comes from a correction that cannot be guaranteed to arrive.
Join the Game?
Monday 11 to 1pm, Zest, Ubud, Bali
Wednesday 5 to 7 pm, La Portal, Ubud, Bali
PS: “Change Your Story, Change The World” is a storytelling endeavor that looks deeply into the psyche that creates the stories we live by.
Because the stories we tell are the reality we live.
SOURCES
Finding: Three disclosure–liking effects
Reference: Collins, N. L., & Miller, L. C. (1994). Self-disclosure and liking: a meta-analytic review. Psychological Bulletin, 116(3), 457–475. PubMed
Finding: Pluralistic ignorance, campus drinking
Reference: Prentice, D. A., & Miller, D. T. (1993). Pluralistic ignorance and alcohol use on campus. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 64(2), 243–256. Princeton
Finding: Intimacy as an interpersonal process
Reference: Reis, H. T., & Shaver, P. (1988). Intimacy as an interpersonal process. In S. Duck (Ed.), Handbook of Personal Relationships, 367–389. Wiley.
Finding: Responsiveness outweighs disclosure
Reference: Laurenceau, J.-P., Feldman Barrett, L., & Rovine, M. J. (2005). The interpersonal process model of intimacy in marriage. Journal of Family Psychology, 19(2), 314–323. PDF
Finding: Affect labeling and the amygdala
Reference: Lieberman, M. D., et al. (2007). Putting feelings into words. Psychological Science, 18(5), 421–428. PDF
Finding: Expressive disclosure meta-analysis
Reference: Frattaroli, J. (2006). Experimental disclosure and its moderators: a meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 132(6), 823–865. PDF
Finding: The burden of secrets
Reference: Slepian, M. L., Chun, J. S., & Mason, M. F. (2017). The experience of secrecy. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 113(1), 1–33. Columbia
Finding: The liking gap
Reference: Boothby, E. J., Cooney, G., Sandstrom, G. M., & Clark, M. S. (2018). The liking gap in conversations. Psychological Science, 29(11), 1742–1756. PDF
Finding: Beautiful mess effect
Reference: Bruk, A., Scholl, S. G., & Bless, H. (2018). Beautiful mess effect: self–other differences in evaluation of showing vulnerability. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 115(2), 192–205. Mannheim
Finding: Therapeutic factors in groups
Reference: Yalom, I. D., & Leszcz, M. (2005). The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy (5th ed.). Basic Books.
Finding: Origin of the term
Reference: Allport, F. H., & Katz, D. (1931). Students’ Attitudes. Craftsman Press.



Brilliant game and analysis.
I am part of a community now which has "small groups." Only 8 people, and a few questions. Then active listening, no interruptions, no advice can be offered, and no response can be given.
Do you know how hard that is? But also, it's the most liberating feeling, both for the speaker, and the listeners.
I would imagine the Authenticity Game requires a little courage though! :)